Limits of Interference by Constitutional Courts in Police Investigation”.

In the context of the society that, we are living in now, constitutional freedom is a sine qua non for every citizen to expect a fair dealing by public authorities including the police. It is in this regard, essential to consider and deliberate on the topical issue such as to assess the extent to which constitutional courts in this country can at the very inception of a criminal process or enquiry interdict the public authorities which may include the police, the State or other statutory authorities start to regulate or monitor investigations on the apprehension of abuse of power or process. The role of the police in public life, maintenance of law and order, and public security is uncontested yet, should not courts more particularly constitutional courts if apprised of violations which can harbour on trampling on citizens’ rights guaranteed more specifically under Article 21 of the Constitution, step in to make course corrections and direct authorities including the police to follow the mandate of law. 

Introduction:

It is not peculiar to observe a pattern of abuse of power among those who are charged to protect the citizenry. Interestingly, the history of Imperial Rome was one that was marked by ascendency of the Praetorian Guards in whom vested not just the protection of the Emperors’, but also protection and security of the citizens of Rome. With passage of time, these ‘men-at-arms’ who were charged with protection of the citizens, came to be used in sinister tasks of confining and often exterminating those who were considered a threat to the Emperor. Soon the nature of excesses of the Praetorians reached such levels that the citizens were intimidated by the presence of the Praetorian Guards to the extent of being forced to commit suicide. And so the ancient Roman adage of ‘Who will guard against the Praetorians’ has often found resonance in periods of history marked by oppression of those in whom is vested the onerous task of protecting the public. For long the relationship between the police as protectors of the citizenry, and the courts as final arbiters of law has remained tenuous, and cataclysmic. In India, the relationship between the law enforcement agencies and the courts has been uneasy. A spate of landmark cases have catapulted to national spotlight the growing discomfort of the courts in India with the diminishing standards of investigation conducted by law enforcement agencies. While courts in India are conscious of maintaining the constitutional balance of power by not engaging in the judicial overreach or encroaching upon the primary spheres of influence of executive power; however, increased executive interference in critical cases has forced to courts to oversee the investigative process conducted by law enforcement agencies to ensure free, impartial and independent investigation which secure the ends of justice.

Leading Cases

In recent times, a spate of cases have constrained the Supreme Court of India to review the modus operandi of police investigation. But in the BhimaKoregaon case[1] (vide Order dated 28 September 2018) involving arrest of five self-styled human rights activists, Advocates, and journalists whose arrests were challenged by certain social activists and “eminent personalities” who approached the Supreme Court under Article 32 of the Constitution alleging high-handedness by the Maharashtra Police while raiding their homes and arresting them for espousing a contrarian theory of dissent to which the ruling dispension did not agree to. The action of the police was based on offences under the Indian Penal Code, the Arms Act and the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967.

The Hon’ble Supreme Court (2:1) by a majority judgment inter alia declined to appoint a SIT probe while allowing the Pune police to investigate the arrests of five (5) activists involved in the BhimaKoregaon Dalit agitations. It was urged before the Court by the State of Maharashtra that the State had not trampled upon any expression of political dissent but instead relied on strong digital evidence of Maoist links and plans of conspiracy against security forces to arrest the activists.

The Court observed:

Upon perusal of the material (given by the investigating agency), we are of the considered opinion that it is not a case of arrest because of mere dissenting views expressed or difference in the political ideology of the named accused, but concerning their link with the members of banned organisation and its activities…”               (emphasis supplied)

The Court, however, in its dissenting opinion given by Justice DY Chandrachud opined:

The court has to be vigilant in the exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 32 of the Indian Constitution to ensure that liberty is not sacrificed at the altar of conjectures. Individuals who assert causes which may be unpopular to the echelons of power are yet entitled to the freedoms which are guaranteed by the Constitution. Dissent is a vital symbol of a vibrant democracy…”

In contrast, the majority opinion represented by Dipak Mishra and A. Khanwilkar, JJ. relied on the position of the Apex Court in Narmada Bai v. State of Gujarat[2] (Tulsiram Prajapati murder case) to decide whether the accused persons can choose which investigative agency must investigate the offence committed by them. The Bench noted:

The accused cannot ask for changing the investigating agency or to do investigation in a particular manner, including for court-monitored investigation

The Bench also relied on Divine Retreat v. State of Kerala[3], where it was held that “Court in exercise of its inherent jurisdiction cannot change the investigating officer in the midstream and appoint an investigating officer of its own choice to investigate into a crime on whatsoever basis….(but) the High Court in exercise of its power under Article 226 of the Constitution can always issue appropriate directions at the instance of the aggrieved person if the High Court is convinced that the power of investigation has been exercised by the investigating officer mala fide”.

The Bench also relied on the position explicated in State of West Bengal v. Committee for Protection of Democratic RightsWest Bengal,[4] where the Court held:

“…Courts must bear in mind certain self-imposed limitations on the exercise of these Constitutional powers. The very plenitude of the power under the said articles requires great caution in its exercise. Insofar as the question of issuing a direction to the CBI to conduct investigation in a case is concerned, although no inflexible guidelines can be laid down to decide whether or not such power should be exercised but time and again it has been reiterated that such an order is not to be passed as a matter of routine or merely because a party has levelled some allegations against the local police. This extraordinary power must be exercised sparingly, cautiously and in exceptional situations where it becomes necessary to provide credibility and instil confidence in investigations or where the incident may have national and international ramifications or where such an order may be necessary for doing complete justice and enforcing the fundamental rightsOtherwise the CBI would be flooded with a large number of cases and with limited resources, may find it difficult to properly investigate even serious cases and in the process lose its credibility and purpose with unsatisfactory investigations.”                                 (emphasis supplied)

However, Justice Chandrachud questioned “whether the Pune police can be trusted to carry out impartial investigation” given that it had already prejudiced public opinion by going public with the evidence which was a “disconcerting behaviour”. He noted:

The police are not adjudicators nor do they pronounce upon guiltIn the present case, police briefings to the media have become a source of manipulating public opinion by besmirching the reputations of individuals involved in the process of investigation. What follows is unfortunately a trial by the media. That the police should lend themselves to this process is a matter of grave concernThe conduct of the Pune police in utilising the agency of the electronic media to cast aspersions on those under investigation fortifies the need for an investigation which is fairWhen the Joint Commissioner of Police and the Additional Director General of Police cast aspersions in the public media against persons whose conduct is still under investigation, and in disregard of proceedings pending before a judicial forum, it is the duty and obligation of this court to ensure that the administration of criminal justice is not derailed.”                       (emphasis supplied)

Per contra, Justice Chandrachud, therefore, ordered a Court directed SIT probe noting that the mere technicalities of law cannot override substantive justice. He further added that “the basic entitlement of every citizen faced with allegations of criminal wrongdoing is that the investigative process should be fair…(and) if (the) Court were not to stand by the principles which have formulated, (there would be) a soulful requiem to liberty”, and that, “in the interest of justice, and particularly when there are serious doubts regarding the investigation being carried out, it is not only permissible, but our constitutional duty to ensure that the investigation is carried out by a special investigation team or a special investigative agency so that justice is not compromised”                                   (emphasis supplied)

He further relied on the guidelines of arrest set in the DK Basu v. State of West Bengal,[5] where the Supreme Court noted that “the requirements (of arrest) enunciated (in) Articles 21 and 22(1) of the Constitution and need to be strictly followed failing which action for contempt of court would be initiated…”

Conclusion

Thus, the judicial history of India is interspersed with uneasy calm over the nature of investigative process undertaken by the law enforcement agencies requiring constant intervention by the higher judiciary to ensure an impartial and independent enquiry. These custodians of public security in India stand at the cusp of change. Like the Praetorians of ancient Rome whose service was often marred by their treacherousness and oppression towards both emperors and the citizenry; so also the police in India as guardians of public security have much to regain in terms of the loss of public confidence in discharge of their public duties. The growing use of unbridled authority, servitude to political masters rather than service to the citizenry, and diminishing standards of accountability, all underscore the need for watching over these ‘praetorians’ under the gaze of the courts of justice. Unless systems of self-governance and accountability are embedded in the police system in India, and public confidence is infused in the integrity of the investigating process undertaken by the investigative agencies and the police system, the only haven of hope for the aggrieved citizens will continue at the doorstep of the sentinels of justice.

To suggest in absoluteness that in a given case where gross abuse of police powers is writ large a constitutional court can never step in, would be doing injustice to the constitutional protective scheme of the country. However, since adequate safeguards are ingrained in the Criminal Procedure Code and other penal statutes, to not give elbow room to the authorities to do their job would mean a lack of confidence in the system as a whole and would not ennure to the benefit of anyone however, for third parties not connected with the commission of an offence to invoke the jurisdiction of constitutional courts, if allowed, would result in, if one may be permitted to say, in JUDICIAL ANARCHY.

Rana Mukherjee, Senior Advocate, Supreme Court of India

President, Adivakta Parishad Supreme Unit Court, New Delhi

[1] Romila Thapar v. Union of India, Writ Petition (Crim.) 260 of 2018.

[2] (2011) 5 SCC 79, paragraph 64; See also, Rubabbuddin Sheikh v. State of Gujarat (2007) 4 SCC 318; (2010) 2 SCC.

[3] (2008) 3 SCC 542

[4] (2010) 3 SCC 571, Paragraph 70.

[5] (1997) 1 SCC 416

Similar Posts

397 Comments

  1. PP Pipes in Iraq Elite Pipe Factory in Iraq specializes in the production of PP pipes, which are known for their excellent chemical resistance, high impact strength, and thermal stability. Our PP pipes are designed to meet stringent quality standards, making them a reliable choice for industrial and commercial applications. As one of the best and most reliable pipe manufacturers in Iraq, Elite Pipe Factory ensures that our PP pipes deliver superior performance and durability. Explore our range of PP pipes by visiting elitepipeiraq.com.

  2. Thank you for your sharing. I am worried that I lack creative ideas. It is your article that makes me full of hope. Thank you. But, I have a question, can you help me?

  3. شركة Bwer هي أحد الموردين الرئيسيين لموازين الشاحنات ذات الجسور في العراق، حيث تقدم مجموعة كاملة من الحلول لقياس حمولة المركبات بدقة. وتغطي خدماتها كل جانب من جوانب موازين الشاحنات، من تركيب وصيانة موازين الشاحنات إلى المعايرة والإصلاح. تقدم شركة Bwer موازين شاحنات تجارية وموازين شاحنات صناعية وأنظمة موازين جسور محورية، مصممة لتلبية متطلبات التطبيقات الثقيلة. تتضمن موازين الشاحنات الإلكترونية وموازين الشاحنات الرقمية من شركة Bwer تقنية متقدمة، مما يضمن قياسات دقيقة وموثوقة. تم تصميم موازين الشاحنات الثقيلة الخاصة بهم للبيئات الوعرة، مما يجعلها مناسبة للصناعات مثل الخدمات اللوجستية والزراعة والبناء. سواء كنت تبحث عن موازين شاحنات للبيع أو الإيجار أو التأجير، توفر شركة Bwer خيارات مرنة لتناسب احتياجاتك، بما في ذلك أجزاء موازين الشاحنات والملحقات والبرامج لتحسين الأداء. بصفتها شركة مصنعة موثوقة لموازين الشاحنات، تقدم شركة Bwer خدمات معايرة موازين الشاحنات المعتمدة، مما يضمن الامتثال لمعايير الصناعة. تشمل خدماتها فحص موازين الشاحنات والشهادات وخدمات الإصلاح، مما يدعم موثوقية أنظمة موازين الشاحنات الخاصة بك على المدى الطويل. بفضل فريق من الخبراء، تضمن شركة Bwer تركيب وصيانة موازين الشاحنات بسلاسة، مما يحافظ على سير عملياتك بسلاسة. لمزيد من المعلومات حول أسعار موازين الشاحنات، وتكاليف التركيب، أو لمعرفة المزيد عن مجموعة موازين الشاحنات ذات الجسور وغيرها من المنتجات، تفضل بزيارة موقع شركة Bwer على الإنترنت على bwerpipes.com

  4. Keep up the fantastic work! Kalorifer Sobası odun, kömür, pelet gibi yakıtlarla çalışan ve ısıtma işlevi gören bir soba türüdür. Kalorifer Sobası içindeki yakıtın yanmasıyla oluşan ısıyı doğrudan çevresine yayar ve aynı zamanda suyun ısınmasını sağlar.

  5. Thank you for your sharing. I am worried that I lack creative ideas. It is your article that makes me full of hope. Thank you. But, I have a question, can you help me?

  6. Thank you for your sharing. I am worried that I lack creative ideas. It is your article that makes me full of hope. Thank you. But, I have a question, can you help me?

  7. Thank you for your sharing. I am worried that I lack creative ideas. It is your article that makes me full of hope. Thank you. But, I have a question, can you help me?

  8. شركة Bwer هي أحد الموردين الرئيسيين لموازين الشاحنات ذات الجسور في العراق، حيث تقدم مجموعة كاملة من الحلول لقياس حمولة المركبات بدقة. وتغطي خدماتها كل جانب من جوانب موازين الشاحنات، من تركيب وصيانة موازين الشاحنات إلى المعايرة والإصلاح. تقدم شركة Bwer موازين شاحنات تجارية وموازين شاحنات صناعية وأنظمة موازين جسور محورية، مصممة لتلبية متطلبات التطبيقات الثقيلة. تتضمن موازين الشاحنات الإلكترونية وموازين الشاحنات الرقمية من شركة Bwer تقنية متقدمة، مما يضمن قياسات دقيقة وموثوقة. تم تصميم موازين الشاحنات الثقيلة الخاصة بهم للبيئات الوعرة، مما يجعلها مناسبة للصناعات مثل الخدمات اللوجستية والزراعة والبناء. سواء كنت تبحث عن موازين شاحنات للبيع أو الإيجار أو التأجير، توفر شركة Bwer خيارات مرنة لتناسب احتياجاتك، بما في ذلك أجزاء موازين الشاحنات والملحقات والبرامج لتحسين الأداء. بصفتها شركة مصنعة موثوقة لموازين الشاحنات، تقدم شركة Bwer خدمات معايرة موازين الشاحنات المعتمدة، مما يضمن الامتثال لمعايير الصناعة. تشمل خدماتها فحص موازين الشاحنات والشهادات وخدمات الإصلاح، مما يدعم موثوقية أنظمة موازين الشاحنات الخاصة بك على المدى الطويل. بفضل فريق من الخبراء، تضمن شركة Bwer تركيب وصيانة موازين الشاحنات بسلاسة، مما يحافظ على سير عملياتك بسلاسة. لمزيد من المعلومات حول أسعار موازين الشاحنات، وتكاليف التركيب، أو لمعرفة المزيد عن مجموعة موازين الشاحنات ذات الجسور وغيرها من المنتجات، تفضل بزيارة موقع شركة Bwer على الإنترنت على bwerpipes.com

  9. Bwer Company is a top supplier of weighbridge truck scales in Iraq, providing a complete range of solutions for accurate vehicle load measurement. Their services cover every aspect of truck scales, from truck scale installation and maintenance to calibration and repair. Bwer Company offers commercial truck scales, industrial truck scales, and axle weighbridge systems, tailored to meet the demands of heavy-duty applications. Bwer Company’s electronic truck scales and digital truck scales incorporate advanced technology, ensuring precise and reliable measurements. Their heavy-duty truck scales are engineered for rugged environments, making them suitable for industries such as logistics, agriculture, and construction. Whether you’re looking for truck scales for sale, rental, or lease, Bwer Company provides flexible options to match your needs, including truck scale parts, accessories, and software for enhanced performance. As trusted truck scale manufacturers, Bwer Company offers certified truck scale calibration services, ensuring compliance with industry standards. Their services include truck scale inspection, certification, and repair services, supporting the long-term reliability of your truck scale systems. With a team of experts, Bwer Company ensures seamless truck scale installation and maintenance, keeping your operations running smoothly. For more information on truck scale prices, installation costs, or to learn about their range of weighbridge truck scales and other products, visit Bwer Company’s website at bwerpipes.com.

  10. شركة Bwer هي أحد الموردين الرئيسيين لموازين الشاحنات ذات الجسور في العراق، حيث تقدم مجموعة كاملة من الحلول لقياس حمولة المركبات بدقة. وتغطي خدماتها كل جانب من جوانب موازين الشاحنات، من تركيب وصيانة موازين الشاحنات إلى المعايرة والإصلاح. تقدم شركة Bwer موازين شاحنات تجارية وموازين شاحنات صناعية وأنظمة موازين جسور محورية، مصممة لتلبية متطلبات التطبيقات الثقيلة. تتضمن موازين الشاحنات الإلكترونية وموازين الشاحنات الرقمية من شركة Bwer تقنية متقدمة، مما يضمن قياسات دقيقة وموثوقة. تم تصميم موازين الشاحنات الثقيلة الخاصة بهم للبيئات الوعرة، مما يجعلها مناسبة للصناعات مثل الخدمات اللوجستية والزراعة والبناء. سواء كنت تبحث عن موازين شاحنات للبيع أو الإيجار أو التأجير، توفر شركة Bwer خيارات مرنة لتناسب احتياجاتك، بما في ذلك أجزاء موازين الشاحنات والملحقات والبرامج لتحسين الأداء. بصفتها شركة مصنعة موثوقة لموازين الشاحنات، تقدم شركة Bwer خدمات معايرة موازين الشاحنات المعتمدة، مما يضمن الامتثال لمعايير الصناعة. تشمل خدماتها فحص موازين الشاحنات والشهادات وخدمات الإصلاح، مما يدعم موثوقية أنظمة موازين الشاحنات الخاصة بك على المدى الطويل. بفضل فريق من الخبراء، تضمن شركة Bwer تركيب وصيانة موازين الشاحنات بسلاسة، مما يحافظ على سير عملياتك بسلاسة. لمزيد من المعلومات حول أسعار موازين الشاحنات، وتكاليف التركيب، أو لمعرفة المزيد عن مجموعة موازين الشاحنات ذات الجسور وغيرها من المنتجات، تفضل بزيارة موقع شركة Bwer على الإنترنت على bwerpipes.com

  11. Thank you for your sharing. I am worried that I lack creative ideas. It is your article that makes me full of hope. Thank you. But, I have a question, can you help me?

  12. If you’re a fan of action-packed fruit-slicing games, Slice Master is a title you don’t want to miss. With its latest upgrade available at Slicemaster.net, this beloved game has been taken to a whole new level.

  13. iwin – Noi quy tu dang cap cua gioi thuong luu, la mot trong nhung cong game bai doi thuong uy tin nhat hien nay tai thi truong Chau A. cffresearch.org

  14. Looking for an exciting game that challenges your skills, keeps you engaged, and helps you unwind? Run 3 is the perfect choice for anyone who loves endless running games but wants a unique twist. run3.app

  15. https://brothel.lat/rcvavmnbqtzalca Are you ready to find someone who truly gets you? Our dating website connects people for meaningful relationships. Create connections that go beyond surface-level interactions. Meet new people with similar desires and passions. Every conversation could be the beginning of something incredible. Security and privacy are at the heart of our platform. Explore the world of online dating with innovative and fun tools. Whether it’s love or companionship look for what you’re searching for on this site. Be excited about daily connections. The perfect match is waiting for you to sign up today and discover for yourself!

  16. Looking for an exciting game that challenges your skills, keeps you engaged, and helps you unwind? Run 3 is the perfect choice for anyone who loves endless running games but wants a unique twist.

  17. Kubet – Link vao trang chu KU BET moi nhat 2024. KUBET88 chuan dang co khuyen mai 88k danh cho hoi vien moi, tham gia ngay hom nay. markusklinko-indrani.com

  18. Nhung tro choi hay nhat, HOT nhat tai KUBET dang thu hut rat nhieu nguoi choi. Hay nhanh chong tham gia va the hien kha nang cua ban voi nhung co gai xinh dep ngay nao! cfp2020.us

  19. Hoi tu nhieu game hay da dang the loai nhu the thao, xo so, game bai doi thuong, casino online, ban ca, slot, lo de online, Loc79 duoc danh gia cao vi chieu long nhieu khach choi de dang. loc79.app

  20. 188Bet is a corporation that meets reputable bookmaker standards, currently ranked top 1 in Asia. With a variety of products from online soccer betting, online casino to top card games, 188 Bet always maintains its position against other competitors such as W88, M88, FB88…

  21. Bong88
    is the leading online betting platform for sports and entertainment enthusiasts. At Bong 88, we are proud to bring you the perfect betting experience with a variety of attractive odds and odds, from soccer, basketball to e-sports.

  22. Vin777- a classy gaming portal where dreams of winning come true! From slot machines to, Vin777 offers a unique and exciting gaming experience. Join now to conquer!

  23. 99OK is the most VIP online casino house in Vietnam, 99ok com offers a diverse game store from football betting, Sic Bo, lottery to interesting casino games. With a smooth interface, attractive promotions and strong security system, 99OK certainly brings you a top-notch, safe betting experience.

  24. 77bet is the ultimate entertainment paradise, where players can freely experience a variety of rich games, from sports betting to online . With a luxurious and easy-to-use interface, 77bet brings moments of suspense, drama and the opportunity to win big that cannot be missed.

  25. KING88 – thiên đường cá cược trực tuyến cho mọi tín đồ đam mê thử thách! Với đa dạng trò chơi từ casino, cá cược thể thao, đá gà, bắn cá,… King88 mang đến trải nghiệm đỉnh cao, cơ hội thắng lớn và ưu đãi hấp dẫn. Tham gia ngay để khám phá!

  26. IWIN68 – Home page to download IWIN68 club for APK/IOS, official online reward game portal giving away code 99K at iwin68-club.net. IWIN68 is the leading online prize exchange card game portal in Asia, with many attractive games including crabs, coin toss, Sic Bo, casino, sports,… https://iwin68-club.net/

  27. Ole777 – nen tang giai tri chuyen nghiep chat luong cao, dat chi tieu kiem dinh va duoc cap phep boi chinh phu Philippines. Noi bat voi kho tro choi da dang, khuyen mai hap dan, thanh toan sieu toc, ho tro thanh vien tan tam, chuyen nghiep,…

  28. HDBet – Nha cai Top 1 Chau Au, noi bat voi ty le cuoc hap dan va dich vu chuyen nghiep. Kho game da dang tu Bong da, Ban Ca, Baccarat den Slots se dap ung moi nhu cau giai tri cua ban.

  29. Vip79 la nen tang giai tri truc tuyen hang dau hien nay. Cong game duoc dong dao nguoi choi yeu thich va tin tuong trai nghiem. Voi kho game da dang, phong phu va chat luong dich vu tuyet voi, cong game da nhanh chong khang dinh vi the cua minh tren thi truong.

  30. fun88 la nha cai uy tin va noi tieng hang dau tai chau A, duoc hang trieu nguoi choi tin tuong lua chon. Voi link vao chinh thuc duoc cap nhat moi nhat thang 12/2024. fun88b.co

  31. Hen88 – Number 1 Redemption Card Game Portal in Asia 2025 | Link to Hen88 Club Game Portal, Hen88 Game Download, Hen88 info. Hen88 withdraws real money anytime, anywhere. Hen88 is a super-fast card game portal with a variety of super attractive slot games, casinos, card games, lotteries, sports, and jackpots. Deposits and withdrawals are fast, safe and absolutely confidential. Continuously update the latest game download links. Free new player code 88k, register now to receive great deals: https://hen88.info/

  32. Thank you for your sharing. I am worried that I lack creative ideas. It is your article that makes me full of hope. Thank you. But, I have a question, can you help me?

  33. MAX88 – Đẳng cấp cá cược online đến từ Anh Quốc. Thử sức với MAX88 qua các trò chơi như Tài Xỉu, Xóc đĩa và Cá cược bóng đá .

  34. GEMWIN | Trang chủ tải Gem Win 2025 – Game bài đại phú quý, Chơi thả ga, nhận thưởng khủng, cơ hội trở thành tỷ phú nhận ngay code 100k!

  35. IWIN là một sòng bạc thượng lưu chuyên đánh bài ăn tiền thật xanh chín Châu Á, iwin club cung cấp nhiều sản phẩm cá cược trực tuyến online uy tín chất lượng như: bắn cá, đá gà, game bài, nổ hũ, lô đề, cá độ thể thao. Đặc biệt tham gia iwin nhận code khuyến mãi liên tục được cổng game phát hằng tuần

  36. Jun88 la mot trong nhung nen tang ca cuoc truc tuyen hang dau tai Viet Nam, mang den cho nguoi choi nhung trai nghiem giai tri tuyet voi voi nhieu san pham da dang. 2021hkcharter.com

  37. Chao mung ban den voi 789bet , nen tang giai tri truc tuyen uy tin va chuyen nghiep. Chung toi cung cap da dang tro choi tu ca cuoc the thao truc tuyen den ban ca,va no hu. 789bet.fail

  38. 789club không chỉ là một nền tảng giải trí mà còn là nơi hội tụ của các trò chơi đẳng cấp. Với giao diện đẹp mắt, bảo mật tuyệt đối và dịch vụ tận tâm, 789club đã trở thành lựa chọn hàng đầu của người chơi. Tải ngay để không bỏ lỡ cơ hội!

  39. Zumvip la trang game chua bao gio het hot tren thi truong hien nay. Voi nhung uu the ve do uy tin, da dang game choi da mang den cho nguoi choi nhung trai nghiem hap dan. zumvip.net

  40. MAX88 – Đẳng cấp cá cược online đến từ Anh Quốc. Thử sức với MAX88 qua các trò chơi như Tài Xỉu, Xóc đĩa và Cá cược bóng đá .

  41. HEN88 là cổng game bài đổi thưởng hàng đầu tại Việt Nam, nổi bật với sự đa dạng trong các thể loại trò chơi. Từ slot game, xì dách, đến poker, mỗi game đều mang lại trải nghiệm độc đáo với đồ họa sắc nét và âm thanh sống động

  42. MAX88 – Đẳng cấp cá cược online đến từ Anh Quốc. Thử sức với MAX88 qua các trò chơi như Tài Xỉu, Xóc đĩa và Cá cược bóng đá .

  43. HUVIP88 – Cổng game đổi thưởng uy tín năm 2025 với hệ thống trò chơi phong phú từ game bài truyền thống đến các trò chơi mới lạ như Đua ngựa, Nổ hũ, Bắn cá, Rồng hổ, và Slot Games. Người chơi có thể trải nghiệm cảm giác hồi hộp với tài xỉu, xóc đĩa, bầu cua cùng nhiều tính năng độc đáo.

  44. BOM86 là cổng game đổi thưởng đẳng cấp nhất hiện nay. Tại đây mọi người sẽ được trải nghiệm các game cá cược hấp dẫn như casino online , game bài và bắn cá.

  45. SAM86 – Đẳng cấp và uy tín là các nhận xét từ người chơi đến cổng game đổi thưởng này. Người chơi hoàn toàn có thể yên tâm trải nghiệm các trò chơi các cược như xóc đĩa, tài xỉu, bắn cá và slot tại đây.

  46. VB88 là nhà cái được đầu tư kỹ lưỡng, bảo mật cao và uy tín đến từ Dubai. Muôn vàn trò chơi cá cược thể thao như bóng đá , liên minh huyền thoại và các thể loại casino game bài, tài xỉu, xóc đĩa. Đi kèm là kho game nổ hũ và slot được thiết kế đẹp đẽ bắt mắt.

  47. XO88 là nhà cái đẳng cấp từ Anh Quốc, cung cấp đa dạng trò chơi cá cược online như bóng đá, casino trực tuyến, xóc đĩa, tài xỉu và nổ hũ. Tham gia ngay để trải nghiệm!

  48. If you’re a fan of action-packed fruit-slicing games, Slice Master is a title you don’t want to miss. With its latest upgrade available at Slicemaster.net

  49. Are you ready to reel in the fun? The upgraded version of Tiny Fishing at TheTinyFishing.com takes your fishing experience to a whole new level. Dive into the exciting world of virtual fishing with enhanced features, improved gameplay, and a variety of unique fish waiting to be caught.

  50. HEN88 là cổng game bài đổi thưởng hàng đầu tại Việt Nam, nổi bật với sự đa dạng trong các thể loại trò chơi. Từ slot game, xì dách, đến poker, mỗi game đều mang lại trải nghiệm độc đáo với đồ họa sắc nét và âm thanh sống động

  51. Thank you for your sharing. I am worried that I lack creative ideas. It is your article that makes me full of hope. Thank you. But, I have a question, can you help me?

  52. HDBET là nhà cái cá cược trực tuyến hàng đầu tại Việt Nam, cung cấp đa dạng các trò chơi từ cá cược thể thao đến casino trực tuyến.

  53. Thank you for your sharing. I am worried that I lack creative ideas. It is your article that makes me full of hope. Thank you. But, I have a question, can you help me?

  54. IWIN68 – Trang chủ tải IWIN68 club cho APK/IOS cổng game đổi thưởng trực tuyến chính thức tặng code 99K tại iwin68-club.net IWIN68 cổng game bài đổi thưởng trực tuyến hàng đầu Châu Á với nhiều trò chơi hấp dẫn bầu cua, xóc đĩa, tài xỉu, casino, thể thao…

  55. Game bài đổi thưởng đang trở thành lựa chọn hấp dẫn cho các game thủ yêu thích sự kịch tính và phần thưởng lớn. Với nhiều tựa game đa dạng như Tiến lên, Phỏm, và Xì tố, người chơi có thể trải nghiệm giải trí đỉnh cao và kiếm tiền thật mỗi ngày. Chọn ngay một cổng game uy tín để tận hưởng niềm vui chơi game an toàn.

  56. Android tizimida ishlaydigan qulay dastur izlayapsizmi? Unda siz uchun 888starz apk yuklab olish mukammal tanlovdir. Ushbu ilova barcha foydalanuvchilar uchun qulay va xavfsiz bo‘lib, sportga stavkalar qilish va kazino o‘yinlarida qatnashish imkoniyatini taqdim etadi. Yuklab oling va darhol foydalanishni boshlang.

  57. HDBET nha cai uy tin hang dau Viet Nam duoc thanh lap nam 2018 dat tru so chinh tai Dubai, hoat dong tren thi truong 18 quoc gia va vung lanh tho. HDBET.us la trang chu chinh thuc cua nha cai HDBET.COM, noi ban co the truy cap HDBET ma khong bi chan

  58. 88Goals duoc biet den nha mot nha cai uy tin hang dau khu vuc Chau A. Cac sanh ca cuoc cua nha cai nay duoc dau tu xay dung tren nen tang cong nghe hien dai. Chinh vi vay ma san choi nay duoc cong dong game thu danh gia chat luong dang choi nhat hien nay.

  59. Thank you for your sharing. I am worried that I lack creative ideas. It is your article that makes me full of hope. Thank you. But, I have a question, can you help me?

  60. Wi88 duoc nhieu thanh vien yeu thich va danh gia cao trong gioi nha cai ca cuoc va game bai doi thuong. Neu ban dang tim kiem dia chi uy tin de bat dau trai nghiem cac tro choi ca cuoc va game bai, hay lua chon ngay san choi nay ngay nhe! wi88.nl

  61. you are in reality a just right webmaster The site loading velocity is incredible It seems that you are doing any unique trick In addition The contents are masterwork you have performed a wonderful task on this topicSABA303

  62. Sunwin chính thức cập nhật thêm domain chính hãng sunwin20a.com. Sunwin tặng code tân thủ 199k trong T1 mừng sự kiện ra mắt domain mới tại sunwin20a.com

  63. certainly like your website but you need to take a look at the spelling on quite a few of your posts Many of them are rife with spelling problems and I find it very troublesome to inform the reality nevertheless I will definitely come back again SLOT DANA GOPAY

  64. Строительный и архитектурный портал https://intertools.com.ua все самое интересное о строительстве и архитектуре – новости архитектуры и строительства, обзоры и аналитика.

  65. Welcome to the main page of the fan site http://karim-benzema-english.com dedicated to the world football star – Karim Benzema. Find out everything about his incredible career, incredible achievements and phenomenal skills. Get the latest news, photos and interesting facts about this talented striker. Dive into the exciting world of football with Karim Benzema!

  66. Biography of footballer Zlatan Ibrahimovic zlatan ibrahimovic personal life, his wife Helena Seger, the birth of his sons and rumors of the forward’s infidelity with Diletta Leotta. Club career and playing for the Swedish national team, the athlete’s goals and achievements, his return to FC Milan.

  67. Harry Kane biography harry-kane-bd com personal life, wife and children. The footballer’s club career, his salary and statistics, contract with Tottenham Hotspur. Playing for the England national team, captain’s role at the 2022 World Cup.

  68. Trải nghiệm mượt mà như ý đã giúp SHBet giúp chúng ta được cá cược theo ý muốn đơn giản. Kho game khủng với nhiều trò cược như thể thao, xổ số, game bài đổi thưởng bắn cá, slot, lô đề online… shbet50.one

  69. Натуральные молочные продукты https://gastrodachavselug2.ru свежесть и качество с заботой о вашем здоровье! Широкий выбор: молоко, творог, сметана, сыры. Только натуральные ингредиенты, без консервантов и добавок.

  70. Được ví là sân chơi công bằng, minh bạch, nhân văn hiếm thấy, Shbet gây ấn tượng với giao diện màu Trắng tinh khôi kết hợp gam Xanh biển đại diện cho sự trường thịnh. shbet50.biz

  71. Biography of football player Neymar neymar personal life, relationships and rumors of romances with Katya Safarova, Natalia Barulich, the birth of a son and Bruna’s last girlfriend, the birth of daughters.

  72. Biography of football player Antoine Griezmann antoine-griezmann-bd com personal life, birth of children, national origin. Career now, games for the club Atletico Madrid, striker of the French national team at the European Championship, statistics of matches in the Barcelona team.

  73. Biography of Brazilian and Spanish footballer Vinicius Junior luka-modric the athlete’s career at Real Madrid and the Brazilian national team, personal and team achievements. Personal life, obtaining Spanish citizenship, new girlfriend Kenya Os.

  74. Biography of footballer Toni Kroos toni kroos personal life, relationship with his wife. Announcement of retirement after the Euro, tattoos on his hands. Achievements in the Real Madrid club and the German national team, goals scored, passes made and statistics. Winning trophies. Latest news in 2024.

  75. Biography of football player Jude Bellingham jude-bellingham personal life, relationship with girlfriend Laura. Statistics of the player in the Real Madrid team, matches of the England national team with Harry Kane, the athlete’s salary, conflict with Mason Greenwood.

  76. Thiago Silva thiago silva is a legendary defender for Chelsea and the Brazilian national team. On the site you can find a biography, the latest news, statistics, videos and interviews. Learn everything about the career and achievements of the great football player.

  77. Bukalo Saka bukayo saka com az is one of the brightest and most promising footballers of his generation. His incredible skill, tactical awareness and strong performance on the pitch have already earned him recognition at Arsenal and the England national team.

  78. George Best george-best is a brilliant footballer and a shining symbol of the 1960s, known for his talent and turbulent life. He left an indelible mark on football by combining success on the pitch with the tragedy of personal struggle.

  79. Zico is a legendary Brazilian footballer https://zico.com.az known as “White Pele”. His talent, technique and passion for the game made him an icon of Brazilian football, and his contributions to the sport continue to inspire new generations.

  80. Luka Doncic lukadoncic-az com is a Slovenian basketball player, the leader of the Dallas Mavericks team and one of the main stars of the NBA. His unique playing style, records and influence have made him a symbol of European success in world basketball.

  81. 789bet là Sân chơi công bằng, minh bạch, nhân văn kể trên giúp chúng ta cược thể thao, game bài đổi thưởng, bắn cá, slot, lô đề online, đá gà như ý. tại 789bett.asia

  82. Devin Booker devin-booker-az.com/ is an NBA star, leader of the Phoenix Suns, record-breaker, and master of accurate shots. His path to success is inspiring: from high school talent to superstar, he has become an example of hard work and dedication to the sport.

  83. Biography of footballer Luis Alberto Suarez https://luis-suarez-az.org personal life, wife, children, height. Departure from Atletico Madrid, career at Barcelona and Liverpool, goal statistics. Playing for Gremio, moving to Inter Miami, retirement from international duty and the latest news in 2024.

  84. Talented Nigerian striker Victor Osimhen victor-osimhen-az.com/ proudly represents Italian club Napoli and the Nigerian national team. This story highlights his remarkable sporting career, personal development and notable achievements, including a loan spell at Galatasaray.

  85. Biography of Spanish footballer Rodri rodri Manchester City midfielder, salary, worth, religion, Euro match statistics, champion status and games with Joao Cancelo. Latest updates in 2024.

  86. Nổi bật với màu Xanh biển chủ đạo, Hi88 cho trải nghiệm dịu mắt ngay từ những giây đầu. Nhà cái được Isle of Man, Cagayan Economic Zone and Free Port,M.A.N Entertainment cấp phép hoạt động hợp pháp đến với hi88t.net

  87. Всё для строительства и ремонта https://artpaint.com.ua на одном портале: советы экспертов, обзоры материалов, расчет сметы и готовые решения для вашего дома или бизнеса.

  88. Портал для строительства https://6may.org и ремонта: полезные советы, современные материалы, проекты и идеи. Все, что нужно для воплощения ваших задумок – от фундамента до крыши.

  89. Студия дизайна интерьера https://bconline.com.ua и архитектуры: создаем уникальные проекты для квартир, домов и коммерческих пространств. Эстетика, функциональность и индивидуальный подход – в каждом решении.

  90. Все об озеленении и благоустройстве https://bathen.rv.ua Ландшафтный дизайн, проекты садов, террас и парков. Идеи для создания зеленых зон, подбор растений и профессиональные услуги для вашего участка.

  91. Разработка и продвижение сайтов https://magikfox.ru в Москве и регионах России от диджитал агентства MagicFox. Лучшие цены на рускрутку. Сделаем продающий сайт на Битрикс и обеспечим высокий уровень продаж.

  92. Ваш путеводитель в мире строительства https://dcsms.uzhgorod.ua идеи, планы, пошаговые инструкции и лучшие материалы. Узнайте, как построить дом мечты или обновить интерьер.

  93. Профессиональный портал для строительства https://blogcamp.com.ua проекты, материалы, расчеты, советы и вдохновение. Все, чтобы ваш ремонт или стройка были успешными.

  94. Хотите построить дом https://donbass.org.ua или сделать ремонт? Здесь вы найдете всё: инструкции, идеи, современные технологии и проверенные решения. Портал для тех, кто строит.

  95. Все для строителей и мастеров https://dki.org.ua актуальные технологии, практические советы, строительные материалы и проекты. Простые решения для сложных задач!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *